InCITEful Teaching
InCITEful Teaching is a podcast from Mississippi State University's Center for Innovation and Teaching Excellence featuring conversations with faculty and staff about what's working, what's evolving, and what's worth rethinking in today's classrooms. Hosted by Dr. Shannon Harmon.
InCITEful Teaching
First Days of School: Planning Lessons and Active Engagement
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Even the most thoughtfully designed course comes to life one lesson at a time. In this episode of InCITEful Teaching—part of our First Days of School series—host Dr. Shannon Harmon sits down with Dr. Nicole Miller to explore what happens inside a single class session: how we plan lessons that move students toward our goals, and how we keep them actively engaged along the way.
Dr. Miller is an Associate Professor of Elementary Education in the Department of Teacher Education and Leadership. She earned her Ph.D. in Curriculum and Instruction at Mississippi State, and her background spans both classroom teaching and instructional technology. She also serves as a CITE Faculty Associate, teaching active learning in Maroon Academy, where she helps her peers to think deeply about how to plan purposeful lessons and design learning experiences that invite students in.
Whether you're refreshing a familiar course or getting ready for a brand-new semester, this conversation will help you make each class session count. Listen now and share it with a colleague who's mapping out their next class!
It's hard because we default to lecture because it's comfortable for us. And honestly, it's more comfortable for the students. A lot of times the students will select that as their preferred method of coursework because it's easier for them. They can zone out, they can tune out. And so it doesn't seem as difficult. Well, learning is difficult. And if it's not difficult, then we're not really learning.
Shannon HarmonWelcome to Insightful Teaching, the podcast from the Center for Innovation and Teaching Excellence at Mississippi State University. I'm your host, Dr. Shannon Harmon, and I'm so glad you're here. Today's episode is part of our first days of school series, where we are exploring how faculty can create meaningful learning experiences from the very beginning of the semester. In our last episode, we explored teaching and learning in online environments and how to keep students connected when the classroom is virtual. Today, we're turning our attention to what happens inside a single class session, how we plan lessons that move students towards our goals, and how we keep them actively engaged along the way. Because even the most thoughtfully designed course comes to life one lesson at a time. The choices we make about how to structure a class period, when to talk and when to let students work, and how to invite participation shape whether students are passive observers or active participants in their own learning. Which is why I'm so excited that joining me today is Dr. Nicole Miller, Associate Professor of Elementary Education in the Department of Teacher Education and Leadership here at Mississippi State. Nicole earned her PhD in curriculum and instruction, and her background spans both classroom teaching and instructional technology. Preparing future teachers means she thinks deeply about how to plan purposeful lessons and design active, engaging learning experiences, which makes her the perfect guest for today's conversation. Nicole, I'm so glad you're here. To get us started, can you tell us a little bit about yourself and your work at Mississippi State?
Nicole MIllerSo originally I'm from Los Angeles and I was a middle school teacher for about seven-ish years. I also taught summers and, you know, I was a teaching assistant prior to that. From that context, I had earned my master's degree and then came to Mississippi to earn my PhD. And so I have been teaching here since 2008. And so with that particular background, obviously teaching is central to what I do. While I'm a tenure track faculty, teaching is the core of what I do and kind of my identity. And I know that, you know, with faculty across campus, we don't necessarily, we're not all the same. Some of our roles are different. And so while I do research, um I know some people obviously identify with that researcher role more than the teaching role. Uh, but just, you know, for me, it's teaching is what is my passion.
Shannon HarmonYeah, absolutely. I identify so much with that too. Um, tell me, what do you enjoy most about preparing future teachers?
Nicole MIllerOne, I mean, they're a fun group, to be perfectly honest. Uh, you know, we have a great group of students in our program. They do tend to be overwhelmingly female. I guess. Uh, but uh uh we do occasionally have our male students, which we'd love to have and would love to have more of, especially for elementary education majors. Um, it's just so important and it's definitely something that we've kind of lost over the years. Um, not MSU, but just it's just a in the profession in general. Um, but I think the biggest thing for me is that I get to impact these students who are going to be teachers of hundreds, thousands of students. And so my goal is to really kind of uh share my expertise, my experience with them so that they can go out, be prepared, um, and hopefully stay in the profession and and and provide excellent teaching for their students as well.
Shannon HarmonYeah, that was one of my favorite things too, is to watch the things that I taught them in our methods classes or um in in an experience that they had um even out in the field, but then to watch them in their student teaching years and and see them apply what we've taught them. Um, I think that's what's unique to those of us who teach future teachers.
Nicole MIllerDefinitely. And, you know, it's just obviously with a small town. Um, I think my son has had at least one of my uh former students um in probably three or four years uh, you know, of his of his time. So, you know, I get to see them in that capacity as well.
Shannon HarmonAbsolutely. And I think that's what allows um you to probably reflect even more on your own teaching because you see the end results so much. And so many of our colleagues who maybe are teaching chemistry never get to see the who they, you know, their students once they graduate, what they do later, later and that return um of what they've, you know, been taught. Definitely.
Nicole MIllerAnd I think, you know, it it also keeps me fresh in the sense of there there's always the complaint of the distance between what's happening in K-12 education and what we do, obviously here at Mississippi State to prepare teachers. Uh, also, you know, the fact that I get to teach my classes over at the partnership schools, um, where, you know, we're kind of not embedded fully, but definitely uh we get to see the students on a regular basis, get to interact with teachers, you know, and so that also provides a lens uh to see kind of and keep current with the nature of school, the nature of kids, because kids change. Absolutely change over time. And so I think it's important um to stay connected in those ways as well.
Shannon HarmonYeah, we always have to know who our students are and adapt our learning to them, which is some things we're gonna talk about today. Um, but something you said, so you get to teach at the partnership school, um, which is our middle school that is located here on our campus. And and how awesome is it that we're also building a high school on this campus, so amazing. Um, so how do you describe yourself as a teacher? Are you a um, you know, in the thick of it with them kind of teacher? Are you someone who sits back and lets them what what how do you describe yourself?
Nicole MIllerUm, I think the biggest thing is I I'm concerned about the whole person, the whole student that I have in front of me. Um, and so kind of the idea of everything in my teaching philosophy really goes back to being as student-centered as I can. Um, and so that's really kind of my starting point for anything that I do is not just what I'm teaching them, but are they currently available to listen, to learn, and to participate? Uh, and so, you know, life does happen. And I think that ignoring that is a problem. Uh, you know, I'm lucky enough to have classes that are on the smaller side, under 30 typically, you know, so I'm able to get to know my students in a way that I know that my peers and colleagues here that teach large lecture classes, you know, cannot. Um, but given that I have that opportunity, I think it's important to understand what's going on. And those things also a lot of times inform who they are and who how they're going to become as a teacher. And so, you know, and how they handle those things. And so that becomes kind of a part of um what we call in education a little bit uh the hidden curriculum. Yeah. The things that happen um in teaching that aren't part of my, you know, syllabus uh learning outcomes, uh, but that I still value and think are important.
Shannon HarmonAbsolutely. And I have um, again, also taught smaller classes, but I've also taught bigger, larger classes as well. But we need to think about the whole student all the time, regardless of the size of classroom. We might be able to build a closer relationship in a smaller classroom, but even in those bigger classes, you can still think about the whole learner. Um, and so I think that's very valuable.
Nicole MIllerWell, and I think, I think some of that has to do with how you present yourself in terms of how approachable you seem to be. Um, how much you say, hey, hey, if you are struggling, if you have a problem, I want you to come see me. And not just on day one, yeah, but on day five, on day 10, on day 15, you know, throughout the semester, really communicating with students that um you're there for them if they, if they need assistance, you know. And so, you know, obviously academically, uh, but uh, you know, we're given resources as faculty members that we can provide to our students that they a lot of times are unaware of.
Shannon HarmonYeah. You're kind of describing your teaching philosophy. Yes. So I've got uh I've got well, I also know you, but I have ideas based on what you just said about what your philosophy of teaching is. Will you share that with us and maybe how it's changed over time? Because we don't just walk in and do this magically. This takes some time, right? It does.
Nicole MIllerUm, you know, so in terms of my teaching philosophy, it really, again, it centers on that student-centeredness. Um, and that really evolves from um my original teaching when I was a middle school teacher. And I had a couple of people that I worked with in particular who influenced that. And so I had my kind of classroom mentor teacher, uh, and then an administrator who was originally an assistant principal and then ultimately a principal that I worked for. Uh, but both of them were very, very dedicated to the idea that uh the student comes first. Um, and in some ways, I think she went a little bit far, but it still has uh kind of shaped my thought process, which is uh if a student's not being successful, what are you not doing? Yeah. And um, you know, so that's and and they both shared that to a great deal. I got one time I got into a meeting with the administrator, and it was a 45-minute meeting about me having one student out of 80 who was failing. Um, and so it was a continual question of a lot of what are you doing? And so it forced a lot of self-reflection. Yeah. And so a lot of my teaching philosophy goes back to that too. Um, you know, teaching is not something that uh I do and then I just walk away from it. Um, it's something that, you know, involves a lot of reflection of what worked yesterday, what didn't work, what do I need to go back to because the students don't understand. Uh, and so in terms of that philosophy, and this isn't a formal teaching philosophy per se, but everything I do goes back to the idea of am I serving my students both academically and as people. Yeah.
Shannon HarmonYeah. Absolutely. Because again, you said it earlier, you know, you're preparing future teachers who will then impact the next generation of learners to be hopefully successful members of society, right? Absolutely. Like the the that cycle. Um, and so that's thinking about that and then thinking about your role in that cycle, I think is very um uh admirable for lack of a better word, right now, that you're thinking about that, that's sort of uh honed who you are as a teacher, but then it sounds like as a person as well.
Nicole MIllerAbsolutely. Cause I mean, we're as as teachers, we are very influential. And especially when we're talking about K-12 teachers, very influential in terms of, you know, how our students um succeed. Um, now, granted, you know, they have a role in it too. It's I'm not taking away that component. Um, you know, but who we are and how we translate that into the classroom matters. And, you know, my goal, I I was also I kind of taught a little bit of this and a little bit of that, but you know, helping to develop good people is is as important to me as if as when they would remember my world history content.
Shannon HarmonYeah.
Nicole MIllerYou know, and so, you know, in some ways, that was part of my goal.
Shannon HarmonYeah. And I think that's the might be the misconception that we can't do both at the same time. Right. That we can't teach content, but then also think about the whole student or help uh them be a productive member of the class and and the world. So um you've really you've done a lot of uh talking about um good teaching and being a good teacher. Um, when you picture a strong and engaging lesson, uh, what types of things stand out to you? Because you don't just stand up there and say, I'm gonna teach the content, now I'm gonna teach you how to be a good person. So, what does that look like in action?
Nicole MIllerUm, I think some of it has to do with, you know, getting to know the students. Uh and, you know, for me, typically that includes uh we as a, we're kind of cohorted in in my courses. And so we finally decided to create a singular getting to know you type of survey that we can share across four different classes so that the students have don't have to do that like four times. Um, but it also allows us to ask a longer set of questions so we can get more in depth without it being um too overwhelming. And so that's the first starting point is really getting to know them. And then we also ask questions that get to know them a little bit related to the course content. So, for example, I ask about the nature of their middle school experience because, you know, depending upon the student, that experience could have been pretty rough. Uh, you know, a lot of people have those negative connotations or thoughts about middle the middle years. And uh, so I asked them about that. So that gives me some prior understanding of what they're coming into the course with. My students in particular are interesting because uh they are getting license to teach uh kindergarten through sixth grade. They get endorsements to teach seventh and eighth grade. My stuff kind of focuses on fourth, fifth through eighth grade. Well, I'm gonna tell you right now, the group, one group that I have right now, I don't think there's a single student in that class that wants to teach over third grade. So, you know, it really just lets me come in prepared for who they are, for who they are and you know, which students, you know, really are coming for the significantly focused on middle grades education versus the ones that are taking the class and they may not be happy about it.
Shannon HarmonOkay, but that's gonna resonate, Nicole, with all of our colleagues across campus. Right. Um, because you actually find that out just by a survey. So, regardless of what size our class is or what we're teaching, we can do surveys. Oh, yeah. We can give them a survey online, we can give them a survey on the first day, we can do some of those things. Um, and that's a nice way to just, as you said, start to understand who, the context of your learners, who they are, uh, what they're coming to you, what is their purpose of being there. We I just talked about this with a group of new faculty that sometimes when we know their why or why not, we can then understand how they then move about in our classes. Definitely. Um, so that's very powerful with just something like a survey.
Nicole MIllerAbsolutely. And I use it a lot to you um to connect my content. So even though I'm focused on those older learners, well, not older necessarily, but older than what they're interested in teaching, right? Um, I connect it down a lot. And so I've got one class where I do that more in because there just tend to be for whatever reason, that group is definitely skewed young in younger in terms of the grades that they want to teach. The other one, I've got a lot more students who are interested in teaching that that age group. And so I do a little bit more in-depth there. So it just, it just varies and I try to tailor a little bit here and there in those classes.
Shannon HarmonYeah, I love that. Again, you're allowing them to drive your instructional decisions. Um, and I think that's powerful. Again, that's not something that I think uh anyone can go in, even maybe probably us, when even though we're trained educators, um, I think that's some that's a skill that happens over time. Yeah. So once you have that survey, you said then you make changes uh to what you're gonna do. So someone who maybe um is listening to this and teaches, I don't know, physics or business or something, you know, tell us what that looks like.
Nicole MIllerSo I think I've talked to some people, or at least I've engaged with some people, uh, colleagues uh through Maroon Academy uh who, or even just personally, I'm not sure exactly where, um, but they may teach a variety of different types of future engineers. Right. Or like people with different goals for their chemistry classes and things of that nature. And so kind of having an idea of the mix of people that are in the classroom, it's not about redoing everything that you're teaching. It's about tweaking your examples. It's about connecting those examples to, you know, you've got a bunch of pre-med students, you know. So can you make the scenario that you're teaching with focused on a medical example? Um, can you make it, you know, focused on a civil engineering example? Um, and so it's not about changing the core of what we're teaching, it's just adding to the edges.
Shannon HarmonI love that. Adding to the edges. I'm gonna steal that, Nicole. That's so great. And I love that you brought up Maroon Academy because you are a um site faculty associate and you do teach in our Maroon Academy. Um, this is actually uh engagement, uh, active engagement is what you active learning is what you teach in Maroon Academy. So you have been working with our faculty um across disciplines for many years now. And then we've partnered and been doing some AI training together. Um, and so you are getting to see uh colleagues across disciplines and having uh that impact with them on how to do some of this again, just little by little over time. Um but you and I know that the training, it really is about this, but what do you want your students to know and be able to do? We understand that that content, you know, um, is sometimes it's not about that quantity, it's about the quality of what we do. So, how do we teach um others to think like that, to think about this? What do we want students to know and be able to do versus I've just got to cover all this content so I can't allow for any active engagement?
Nicole MIllerI see this a lot in courses, for example, uh, you know, that either build on one another. So like, and I don't know if this is true, but like a chem one and a chem two. Right. Chem one has to get to a certain point so that chem two can pick up there and get to a certain point, you know, so that they can do what they need to do for whatever other courses or testing that, you know, may be required by that particular profession, you know, whether it be, you know, uh an LSAT or a, you know, the medical school exam. Um, and so we have some of that pressure as well. I've done some things where I have built in additional content that I know that they need to know for the test, but that I don't really care that they know necessarily as much for teaching. And so the content that they need to know for the exam, I tend to put more as homework, online things that I don't necessarily address fully in class. I may quiz them on it and and you know, test them on it periodically. Um it's incorporated in that, but I don't necessarily spend class time there. Um, and so I've designed those activities and things for online learning components as opposed to in class. And so that's one thing that I've definitely done. Absolutely. And so, like, what are my non-negotiables? What are the things that I have to do so that the students can be successful in the next set of courses? And also what I think is personally valuable out in the field. Um, and so that's what I spend my class time on.
Shannon HarmonYeah. I think that's really interesting because um that really comes down to time, right? Oh, there's not enough time ever.
Nicole MIllerI mean, if you teach Tuesday, Thursday this fall, we have 20, you know, uh-huh, we have 28 class sessions. Yeah. 28. It's it's, I mean, you know, so it's it's almost no time at all if you think about it that way.
Shannon HarmonYeah. Okay, thanks for that. So with that though, we do, we kind of default to, well, I'm just gonna lecture for this hour and a half that I've got them, or this three, or whatever this 90-minute period is. Um, I'm gonna just lecture because I I can cover more in that time, then actually think through what this lesson and how I can get them, as you said earlier, happy to be there, engaged, uh, doing. And so, how do you balance delivering content with giving students time to work with it?
Nicole MIllerI think really all content needs to be worked with in some way for it to stick. Um, I actually was talking to my students yesterday about how do we make things sticky, um, you know, so that they can hold on to it. Uh, but, you know, we talked a little bit about the idea that uh it's hard with coverage and things of that nature. We know we do have a lot of content to get through in in 28 class periods or, you know, whatever it may be for your particular class structure. It's never enough time. Um, so you know, some of that flipped learning um will help, you know, where you front-load some content, but with accountability. There's got to be accountability because we know that they will not, they typically will not do things if there's not some sort of carrot uh for them. Uh, but I think when we balance it, uh, we it's hard because we default to lecture because it's comfortable for us. And honestly, it's more comfortable for the students. A lot of times the students will select that as their preferred method of coursework because it's easier for them. They can zone out, they can tune out. Um, and so it doesn't seem as difficult. Well, learning is difficult. And if it's not difficult, then we're not really learning. Um, and so I think a lot of times, you know, when terms of setting up a given class session, I will start out with, you know, the typical reminders, welcome, chit chat, you know, all that kind of stuff. Um, but then I almost always go straight into a brief review of whatever it is that either I front loaded or that we did the previous class session, tie that all together. Then there's a transition introducing what we're going to be doing today, obviously. But then a lot of times it's content practice or apply or review, content practice, apply or review, and trying to get at least two of those segments into a given class session, then obviously ending with some sort of like exit ticket or something of that nature. With that, you know, time sometimes gets away from you. And so what I will sometimes do is I tend to try to prepare an assignment in Canvas that is like for the exit ticket, whether it's one point or whatever I make it worth. Um, and it may just be an assignment that exists that has no content in it, because I know I can quickly type into the and edit a Canvas assignment like on the fly. Like that's not hard for me per se. And I know that I'm a little bit probably more tech fluent than some people, but I can add it in there. Or if I know, oh, I'm afraid this class might go long today. Like this class, I know it could get a little bit longer because we're gonna have more discussion maybe here, then, you know, um, then I will just put it in Canvas. And so either they will complete it in class in Canvas or they can take it home. I keep it to something that's no more than 10 to 15 minutes because we know students are busy and things like that. But uh if I can't get to it, then I they have the opportunity to finish it later.
Shannon HarmonYeah. But you and I know that this is heavily rooted in educational research. And so if we're still doing it many years later, um, from the things that Skinner and Dewey and Vygotsky taught us, if we're still doing these things, we know it has results. Again, maybe not after the one time we do it, but if students do it, uh, as you said, uh over and over again, it will lead to some sticky knowledge. We know that. We know for a fact that's heavily rooted um in research of active learning.
Nicole MIllerAbsolutely. And they just and they have to work with content that they've seen before over time. Um, it's we cannot do a one and done. And so when we're thinking about how we use our Canvas courses and stuff, even if it's things that you not you don't necessarily look at or, you know, are auto-graded, I think it's really important to give students the opportunity to do additional practice if it's not something that you're already doing with the content, even at low levels. You know, a lot of times we skip over some of those lower level thinking of like, do we know the vocabulary? Well, if we don't know the vocabulary, we can't do the work. Um, and so, you know, even at just basic vocabulary practice, just for them to know that. And then if that part of their brain is kind of set, it leaves more space and room for them to apply that learning in more complex ways.
Shannon HarmonAbsolutely. It's getting into maybe that higher levels of bloom, um, where they're engaging and maybe even synthesizing information within the instruction. And then at the end, maybe they go back to recall, right? Yep. Yeah. And so it's about going back and forth on those uh blooms levels, um, right? Uh, and those levels of learning. And so then that again, oftentimes that uh repetition of that type of process leads to learning.
Nicole MIllerThey absolutely need repetition. And it seems, you know, it seems like just low level learning, but it's not. It's essential to everything that we do.
Shannon HarmonIt's really about thinking about strategically that 90 minutes or whatever time you have in your class. What does that look like? Maybe I start with we all have access to Slido here on campus. So we can do that. So that's something that, you know, um, as faculty, we're so fortunate to have that. We can log into our Slido, create a Slido, and insert that. And that's a first step in doing some active learning. And then it gives you data too about what your students know and can do or not. Or not. Uh-huh. Exactly. And so that might be worth a little bit of someone's extra time of planning, regardless of discipline.
Nicole MIllerAbsolutely. And, you know, I I know that uh, you know, I struggle with AI and I'm struggling more with it, you know, with the ethical and the social impacts, environmental impacts, and stuff like that. Um, but in terms of one of the things that it does well, um, or you know, not well, but decently, um, is writing questions. And so if you give it your content, um, you throw your slides into that co-pilot and say, give me questions, uh, it will give you however many you want it to. Now, are they all fantastic? Absolutely not. I have to use my professional judgment and expertise and cull them. And I would say I cull 25 to 50% of them, probably. Yeah. Um, but in terms of time, it's still faster.
Shannon HarmonYeah, I think that's the other thing. You know, we're so fortunate again to have co-pilot and Gemini license that can be protected. And so maybe we do ask co-pilot uh to help us think about how do I turn this class that I normally lecture uh into something more engaging? How do I insert a Slido? What might even I ask in the Slido that's appropriate?
Nicole MIllerUm I think going back to the examples like that we talked about. Like I, you know, you're an X type of engineer, but you have other types of engineers in your program. Can you come up with scenarios or questions that might relate more to their learning and make it feel a little bit more relevant for those specific students as well?
Shannon HarmonI love that. That allows us to then link what we're teaching to the real world, to what's going on out there, to industry. Um, and and Copilot can help give us those, even if we don't have those um, those scenarios or case studies, it can help us link those. I think that's very powerful.
Nicole MIllerI don't use it ever like uh randomly, just you know, because of the impact and stuff. Right. You know, I'm very specific and judicious in my use of AI. Yeah, absolutely. But it does serve a purpose.
Shannon HarmonYeah. So what's one thing you're still working on in your own teaching?
Nicole MIllerSo the thing that I tell my students all the time is the day that they don't have anything that they feel like they need to improve on any given day in teaching is the day that they need to quit. Amen. Because because it's time to go home, right? It's time to go home because we're done. Um, because they're just there's no way that there isn't room for improvement, which makes it hard for a perfectionist, you know.
Shannon HarmonUm but I think we both think that, Nicole. And between the two of us, we have probably 50 years of teaching, right? And we still work on it. We still think about, oh, we could have done that training better. The trainings we've done together, we're like, we should have done this, we should have done that. So the day that we're not thinking about how we can continue to hone our practices, I think that's when it is. It's like, let's let's give up. But I also think that we can say the same same thing for our colleagues who uh make research their number one priority. The day that you're like, I'm done thinking about my research, right? Um, it's time maybe we're doing something else because we're we're burnout. And so I think that's really powerful.
Nicole MIllerUm, I think questioning, honestly, is probably one of the most important things that we do as teachers. And I think it's also probably the hardest to do it well. Um, and so that's something that I'm always very conscious of is trying to make progress in that way. That and also I have really mixed feelings on things like cold calling. Uh, you know, we I at least for me, I have a lot of students, not a lot, but enough students that are very, very anxious uh to speak up in class, um, to the point that it'll be detrimental to their learning. Uh and so, you know, I get uncomfortable with that part of it. And so also trying to get them to participate, you know, is always. And so that's where I think, you know, I always typically try to provide um something where they have to write down jot real quickly their response to a question, at least the really significant ones. Um, and then I'll take people to answer the question so that they've all had time to think about it. And also our students think at different speeds. Uh, you know, so otherwise you end up with the two same students always participating. And, you know, it's always a struggle and always trying to figure that out because, you know, um that's just kind of the way that that classes are, and and you've got some that are real comfortable and some that are not. And so really trying to pull those other students out, it's not one of my strengths and it's something that I always am trying to work on.
Shannon HarmonYeah, again, someone who's been teaching forever and you're still working on questioning. Oh, yeah. And um, you know, I think that's that is actually a great example. Um, I think a lot of our colleagues, that resonates with them. They ask a question and they just hear crickets. Oh, yeah, absolutely. So then they don't ask questions anymore because they don't want to hear crickets. Right. And I think uh that is such a powerful uh lesson for all of us. It's you ask a question, uh, and it's usually uh not a high-stakes question, it's like yes or no, right or wrong questions, or that's when you're gonna get the crickets, but it's in what ways are you thinking about this? Just changing our questioning to that.
Nicole MIllerWell, I think, you know, with the with the yes or no questions or, you know, things like that, there's a lot of really easy things to do where, you know, uh that those I'm actually better with. Um, and so, you know, a lot of times I'll say put one hand over your eyes and then and then we do raise your hand if you agree with this, raise your hand if you disagree, you know, and then I tell them kind of the the numbers, then and then from there we can go why and and elaborate from there. But at least they've all been actively engaged in thinking about the question. And so, you know, that's really the piece that's hard and the piece with active engagement that I think sometimes misconstrue. Active engagement can be invisible. Yes, you know, and so a lot of times they kind of misconstrue it as, oh, we're talking, we're moving, we're doing. But no, I mean, active engagement is really just about are we minds on? Um, the problem is that because we can't see into their brains, we don't know what's happening. So we do have to make them produce something, whether that's raising their hand, answering a question, practicing, et cetera.
Shannon HarmonYeah, absolutely. I love that. This minds own. Instead of just passively getting something, having that. So, what um indicators do you get of your students when their minds are own?
Nicole MIllerI mean, some of it is paying attention, you know, obviously. Um, I am a big proponent of the room scan. I make very, very direct eye contact as I go through the classroom. Um, I need to uh get better. I do get out from behind the podium. I do walk my classroom. I do sit like kind of like between or in front of them as opposed to behind the podium, you know, to also bring them in a little bit more because the podium to me is a distancer. Um it takes us away from our students. Uh, and so I don't like that distance typically, if I can have when I can avoid it. And, you know, you can obviously with an iPad or with a, you know, remote control, depending upon what you're using, what technology you're using and stuff like that. Uh, but uh, you know, I think looking for them, obviously, I they're if they're note-taking, they have something that I have actually copied for them. And I know that that's always the challenge in the sense of like, you know, I know a lot of my colleagues put it online and they don't copy it for the students. And I totally understand why, because it's added effort. Some of you have, you know, limits in terms of what you can do, but really giving them something to anchor them to the instruction that's going on is really important because they just, I mean, in our society today, we have a hard time with attention.
Shannon HarmonYeah, yeah. So giving them that visual. Um, I guess I think that and those things are also appropriate for all learners, right? Oh, absolutely. All learners can benefit from having those things. I love what you just said though about like the proximity. So you put yourself um in their spaces so that builds that uh rapport, that vulnerability, um, physicality. Uh, again, just being near and around students, that you're all a community of learners and you're in that community, learning along with them is so powerful. And again, that's not something that if I walked by your classroom, I would necessarily see in action. It's just something um that I might have to um think about strategically.
Nicole MIllerAnd I think, you know, even in the big lecture halls, yeah. Go up and down the aisles.
Shannon HarmonOkay, so um the second podcast uh that I ever did was with Melissa Moore here on campus, who teaches large lecture, and that's what she does. So uh I asked her to be on the podcast and she said, come to my class first and watch it so that we'll have stuff to talk about. And she was up and down and in this large lecture and off the stage and and getting students, she had 350 students in there. Right. Like she is just like all around the room, and it's amazing. It's amazing. I never like to end a podcast um without thinking about pieces of advice we can give faculty members. Um, so for faculty listening today who were getting ready maybe for their next class, still early in the semester, might even be already thinking about next semester if they're not teaching this one. Um, what are some simple things that they could try either in their very next class or next semester?
Nicole MIllerUm, I think quick writes are really useful. Um, you know, obviously class size matters with that, uh, but uh hopefully maybe you have a GA. Yeah, you know, depending upon the context. But I think there's a lot of questions that you can ask your students at the end of a given um lecture or class session. Um, and I typically like to think of those in two parts, one that's content related and one that's metacognitive. Uh so you know, the first one is I'll ask them some questions or, you know, sometimes it's just, you know, tell me your key three takeaways, your three key takeaways for today. What are the three biggest things that you're taking away that you need to remember long term for becoming a teacher? Um, and so maybe it's just along those lines. Sometimes they're more targeted if I'm trying to make sure that they have some certain concepts down. Um, but even the three key takeaways help me know, okay, well, they weren't, they missed the big one. And so I need to go back and make sure that they prioritize that um in their memory. And then metacognitively, um, I will ask them questions, things like, were there any concepts today that just you really don't understand still, uh, that are really hard and don't make sense? So that I can again go back to those if I need to. Um or what things, you know, am I good on? And so, you know, there's there's a one example of just a purely metacognitive, like exit ticket or quick write, which is a stoplight, you know, red light. Um, I have nowhere to be, I don't even know where to begin with this. You know, yellow, I think I got this, but I there's some nuance here that I'm missing. And green light, go. Like I understand this concept. So again, it really helps me to prioritize my kind of review of the prior class in terms of what things I focus on. Um, and I think that that's really important. And it ties back to really um science of learning stuff, which is that we really need to give our students a lot of space to practice. They need to see content over and over again. They need to come back to it. Um, you know, so if you are using Slido and let's say you have five questions from the previous lecture, no, you do four and do one from the one two times ago. You know, and so bring in some of that previous content because if they're bringing it forward, they're more likely to maintain it. But if they don't do that, it's they're just gonna lose it and they're gonna have to cram for exams.
Shannon HarmonSo powerful. Yes, this idea of uh, you know, I also was a big fan of exit tickets and a three, two, one system. Yep. Three um uh things you've learned today, two questions you still have, one big idea really allowed me to see if what I intended for them to know and be able to do at the end of my class hit or not, and then what I could do about it, right? And then this idea of uh transference from one lesson to the next um and finding out if it is sticking. Right. Those are two things I think any of our colleagues, regardless of discipline, can go in. And I said before, I had a class of 60 one semester and I did a three, two, one on index cards. And thankfully I had a graduate assistant who would then put them in clumps in sections for me. Like here's here's all the index cards of people who are on the right page, here's people that are somewhere in the middle, and here's some that are still, you know, in this area. And then I could make decisions about what to do next class period with those different students.
Nicole MIllerAnd if you do that in a, you know, if you want to do it in technology, absolutely put it into a Microsoft form. Absolutely. Um, and if you put it into a Microsoft form, if you're not opposed to using AI, you could have it summarize and give you some, you know, areas of strength, areas of weakness that it, you know, it determines. Now, of course, it's not perfect, but I also find scanning through their answers in a spreadsheet a little bit more efficient.
Shannon HarmonYeah, absolutely. Um, I loved the index card because again, it was something easy and I didn't have to have a form. You don't have to have a ready and also too, sometimes this is what I say. Like I just carried index cards around with me in my bucket, in my rolling cart. Who doesn't? Who doesn't, right? But I could carry them around. And if I was had a class period where I thought, I need to do this at the end of the class because I'm not sure I'm getting that dazed over look today. So I need to do this so that I then can make instructional decisions. I think even if that wasn't planned, it was something I could do in the moment. Yes, right. And so I think again, that's some advice I would give any of my colleagues.
Nicole MIllerAnd sometimes with the three, two, one, I'll vary it. So, I mean, there's lots of options with it. You just can do three of one thing and two of another. And so, you know, sometimes I did three things from today's class and then I asked them for two things on a topic we studied two weeks ago, and then one question that they may have, or, you know, whatever the case may be, whatever works for your particular content.
Shannon HarmonAbsolutely. There's a plethora of information out there about exit tickets. And again, it can just be it also, I I love Muddiest Point, you know, like what are some of those things? Like again, uh, what are what are you walking away with today? And I think that's important.
Nicole MIllerAnd I'll be honest, you know, obviously we get overwhelmed with other responsibilities, things come up, you know, and so sometimes I think we feel guilty about not necessarily reviewing all of them. Um, but you have to remember that them doing that is still worthwhile, even if you don't look at it, even if you don't have time to look at it. Obviously, I mean, I try to look at everything, you know, and I recommend looking at it as much as we can, but I, you know, it's reality and you can't do it all. Um, and so there's still value in the students doing it, even without the review.
Shannon HarmonBecause it's them then emptying their head with information that they may not even know that they that they got during that lesson or not.
Nicole MIllerAnd they can go back and they can go review their notes and try to see those that content.
Shannon HarmonAbsolutely. It's for them, even if not more than it is for us often. Um, so powerful and such a great thing for um anyone on this campus or beyond to think about as something that they can do that's a that may sound like a small thing, um, but is very active and a way to do um active engagement in your classroom. Nicole, thank you for sharing your expertise and and your passion for this work. That's very evident that you're passionate uh about what you do. And as you said from the very beginning of the podcast, you still think of yourself as, you know, you are a teacher of students and the whole child first. And that's so, that's so powerful. So as we wrap up this conversation, I'm reminded that a great course is really um just a series of things that we put together. Um, it's something that we plan for, it's not something that happens on accident. And as you said yourself, Nicole, it's not something that you just go out and do naturally. You continue to think about your own practice and hone that practice and continue to work on it, whether you're two years in or 20 years in. The choices, though, that we make about how to structure a lesson, when to step back, and how to invite students in determines whether learning is something that happens to our students or something they do. And as you said, it's not always something we see, it's just a process, it's something that occurs in the class. So, colleagues, as you prepare your courses for the weeks ahead, I urge you to consider this question. How might you intentionally create lessons that invite your students to be active learners and engage in their own learning? Whether it's a Slido or an exit ticket or a turn and talk or just thinking about your questions, I really would urge you to think about how you can help your students engage in their learning. Thank you for joining us on Insightful Teaching. If today's episode resonated with you, please share it with a colleague. Until next time, keep teaching with an insightful purpose, keep innovating with an insightful heart, and keep being the reason someone believes they belong here.